Mariah Carey Wins Copyright Battle Over Christmas Classic
#image_title

Mariah Carey Wins Copyright Battle Over Christmas Classic


Share this post

Mariah Carey has been cleared of copyright infringement in a case over her 1994 Christmas staple, All I Want for Christmas is You.

In a ruling issued on Wednesday, a US judge rejected the allegations of songwriter Adam Stone, who released a song with the same name in 1989. He accused Carey of exploiting his "popularity" and "style".

Mr Stone, who performs under the name Vince Vance, was claiming at least $20m (£16m) in damages.

But in her ruling, Judge Mónica Ramírez Almadani cited expert testimony saying the two songs simply shared "Christmas song clichés" that were common to several earlier hits.

Mr Stone and his lawyers had not "met their burden of showing that [the songs by] Carey and Vance are substantially similar", she wrote.

Judge Almandi also ruled that Mr Stone and his lawyers should face sanctions for filing "frivolous" arguments, that included "vague... and incomprehensible mixtures of factual assertions and conclusions, subjective opinions, and other irrelevant evidence".

She ordered Mr Stone and his lawyers to repay the legal bills Carey incurred in defending the case.

The popularity of the song has spawned a side-industry of Mariah Carey Christmas merchandise

The case was originally filed in 2022, with Mr Stone claiming Carey's hit was copied from a song he'd recorded under the name Vince Vance and the Valiants.

In court papers, he claimed his track had received "extensive airplay" during the 1993 holiday season - a year before Carey's song was recorded and released.

In her 2020 memoir, Carey said she had composed "most of the song on a cheap little Casio keyboard", while playing the movie It's A Wonderful Life for inspiration, before completing it in the studio with her co-writer Walter Afanasieff.

But Mr Stone rejected that account.

"[Carey] palmed off these works with her incredulous origin story, as if those works were her own," he said in court papers. "Her hubris knowing no bounds, even her co-credited songwriter doesn't believe the story she has spun."

The initial complaint was dropped in December 2022, but refiled a month later.

Mr Stone had hoped to share in the song's runaway success. All I Want For Christmas Is You earns about $8.5 million (£6.6 million) every year; and has spent 140 weeks in the UK's top 100.

'No similarities'

Carey's lawyers asked the court to dismiss the case last August, arguing that Mr Stone had failed to establish copyright infringement.

"The claimed similarities are an unprotectable jumble of elements: A title and hook phrase used by many earlier Christmas songs, other commonplace words, phrases, and Christmas tropes like 'Santa Claus' and 'mistletoe'," they wrote.

In Wednesday's ruling, Judge Almadani endorsed two reports from musicologists hired by Carey's team.

In one, New York University professor Lawrence Ferrara testified there were "no significant melodic similarities" between the two tracks.

He added he'd discovered "at least 19 songs" predating Mr Stone's track that had similar lyrical ideas - several of which were also called All I Want For Christmas Is You.

A similar report filed by the defence was ruled inadmissible - especially after its author admitted in a deposition that the melodies of the two songs were incomparable because "the rhythms are different".

On that basis, Judge Almadani ruled in favour of the motion to dismiss.

Neither Mariah Carey nor Mr Stone were immediately available for comment on the ruling.


Share this post
Comments

Be the first to know

Join our community and get notified about upcoming stories

Subscribing...
You've been subscribed!
Something went wrong
Trump Revokes Secret Service Protection for Harris Ahead of Book Tour

Trump Revokes Secret Service Protection for Harris Ahead of Book Tour

President Donald Trump has cancelled Secret Service protection for Kamala Harris, which had been extended by Joe Biden before he left office, according to one of her advisers. As a former vice-president, Ms Harris was entitled under law to receive six months of security after leaving office in January, which was due to expire in July. Her protection had been quietly extended for another year by a directive signed by her former boss but was revoked by Trump in a memo dated on Thursday, accordin


O A

French Montana & Sheikha Mahra Confirm Engagement

French Montana & Sheikha Mahra Confirm Engagement

French Montana is starting his next chapter in life with a major gesture of love. The rapper proposed to Princess Sheikha Mahra bint Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum with a diamond ring that carries a price tag of more than one million dollars. The piece was created by Eric the Jeweler of Mavani & Co., who worked closely with French for several months before the final design was completed. The ring features an emerald-cut diamond that weighs 11.53 carats and is valued at approximately $1,050,000


O A

Cam Newton Signs Multi-Year Deal with ESPN

Cam Newton Signs Multi-Year Deal with ESPN

Expect to see more of Cam Newton on ESPN.  The former NFL MVP has signed a muliti-year deal with the network who will expand his role on First Take, ESPN’s signature morning debate show. OnThursday (August 28), Newton made his return during a live show at Norfolk State University as part of the First Take HBCU tour. In a statement, Newton expressed his excitement to be back with the sports network. “I am excited to be back with the First Take team and share my voice on all things sports,” New


O A

Michael Jackson’s Son Prince Announces Engagement to Longtime Girlfriend

Michael Jackson’s Son Prince Announces Engagement to Longtime Girlfriend

Prince Jackson is stepping into a new chapter of his life, and it comes with a big announcement. The 27-year-old son of Michael Jackson revealed that he is now engaged to his longtime partner, Molly Schirmang. On Tuesday, August 27th, he shared the news with his Instagram followers through a carousel of photos that captured some of their happiest moments together. Embed The collection of pictures gave fans a closer look at their relationship, including a photo where Prince and Molly are seen s


O A